
This month I asked ChatGPT a simple question: “Recommend a digital marketing agency in Cleveland, Ohio.”
Burning River Digital made the list. That’s the good news.
The less good news: we weren’t ChatGPT’s first recommendation. We appeared as an alternative “if your priority is paid media, analytics, and attribution.” And it described us as “founded in Cleveland and now based in Florida.”
That isn’t quite right. We have offices in both Cleveland and Naples, Florida, and Northeast Ohio is home. ChatGPT also left out AI search strategy, one of the fastest-growing parts of our work. For an agency that helps clients get found by AI tools, that’s a little humbling.
So we’re doing something about it, in public.
Why this matters for every business
More buyers now start their research by asking an AI assistant instead of typing into a search engine. Prospective students ask which graduate programs fit working professionals. Business owners ask which insurance brokers understand their industry. Marketing directors ask which agencies to call.
The answer they get becomes the first impression. If the AI leaves you out, ranks you second, or gets your details wrong, you may never know you lost the opportunity. And unlike your website or your ads, you don’t get to write that answer directly.
You can influence it, though. That’s what generative engine optimization (GEO) is for.
Where we’re starting: Month 0
Here’s our baseline, as of November 2026:
| Question | Result |
|---|---|
| Is Burning River Digital mentioned? | Yes |
| First recommendation or alternative? | Alternative |
| Location described correctly? | No (“now based in Florida”) |
| Services described | Paid advertising and measurement |
| AI search strategy mentioned? | No |
What we’re going to change
We’re applying the same AI search work we do for clients to our own brand:
- Make our facts consistent everywhere. Our website, Google Business Profiles, LinkedIn and directory listings should all say the same thing: offices in Cleveland and Naples.
- Answer real questions on our site. Clear, direct pages and FAQs on what we do, who we work with and where we are, written so both people and AI tools can understand them.
- Help machines read our site. Structured data (schema markup), an llms.txt file, and making sure AI crawlers aren’t blocked.
- Earn mentions on sites AI tools trust. Industry directories, partner sites, press and community discussions.
- Publish what we know. Regular, specific content on AI search and ChatGPT Ads, like this series.
Follow the experiment
Every month we’ll ask ChatGPT the same question, share the screenshot, and report what we changed and whether it made a difference. Some months the answer may not move at all. We’ll share those too.
In the meantime, try it yourself. Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google’s AI Mode to recommend a company like yours. Are you mentioned? Is the description accurate? Who shows up instead?
If you don’t like the answer, we can help. Request an AI Visibility Audit and we’ll show you how AI tools describe your business compared with your competitors, and what to fix first.
Holly Heritage is the founder and CEO of Burning River Digital, a 2026 Google Premier Partner with offices in Cleveland and Naples.